The U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia has dismissed a lawsuit that challenged a national security exemption from the Endangered Species Act for oil and gas activities in the Gulf of America, the Justice Department said Thursday.
The court ruled that it lacked jurisdiction, meaning legal authority to hear the case. According to the Justice Department, Congress directed challenges to the exemption decisions of the Endangered Species Committee to the federal courts of appeals, not the district courts. The department said the exemption covering oil and gas work in the Gulf of America is still in effect.
The Justice Department’s release said the ruling came “earlier this week” and did not give the exact date. It did not name the environmental groups that brought the case or say whether they plan to appeal.
Congress created the Endangered Species Committee in 1978, according to the release. It has six senior federal officials and is chaired by the Secretary of the Interior. The law lets the committee exempt federal agency actions from the requirements of the Endangered Species Act. The release said the law requires the committee to approve an exemption any time the Secretary of War determines that national security calls for it.
On March 31, the committee voted unanimously to grant the exemption for Gulf of America oil and gas activities, acting on that finding by the Secretary of War. The Justice Department said the committee had never before approved an exemption on national security grounds.
A number of environmental groups later filed lawsuits in district courts. The Justice Department said the district court agreed with its argument in a motion to dismiss. The court concluded that Congress created only one type of exemption and “funneled challenges to those exemptions to the courts of appeals,” according to the release.
The court dismissed the entire case. That included related claims challenging the Secretary of War’s national security finding and claims under the National Environmental Policy Act.
The release said federal courts in the District of Columbia, Maryland and Louisiana earlier this year issued decisions that let the committee’s exemption take effect.
Principal Deputy Assistant Attorney General Adam Gustafson, who works in the department’s Energy and Natural Resources Division, said the exemption is helping maintain domestic production that makes up 15% of the nation’s oil. The release described the Gulf of America as a critical source of domestic production. “Energy security is national security,” Gustafson said.
Attorneys with the division’s Wildlife and Marine Resources Section handled the case, according to the release.