The U.S. Government Accountability Office recommended that Congress change a 1953 law so federally recognized tribes can start a process to return certain state criminal authority in Indian country to the federal government, and so a state cannot make that offer without tribal consent.
The office, known as GAO, released the findings on Nov. 16. It said tribes cannot begin the process, called retrocession, and that tribal consent is not required when a state starts it. Without amendments, GAO said, the law impedes tribes’ efforts to exercise self-determination.
As of October 2026, about 65 percent of the 575 federally recognized tribes were in states covered by the law, according to GAO. In those states, tribes and the state generally share authority to investigate and prosecute certain crimes when a tribal citizen commits a crime or, in some cases, is the victim. In general, tribes and the federal government share authority over certain crimes in Indian country.
The law took most federal criminal authority in Indian country in selected states and gave that authority to those states, GAO said.
Some tribes and local law enforcement agencies have agreements that generally give tribal police officers the same or similar authority as local officers inside and outside Indian country, according to GAO.
Some states have already returned the criminal authority the law gave them to the federal government. Tribal leaders told GAO that retrocession helped strengthen their exercise of self-determination and addressed some difficulties in working with state law enforcement. State law enforcement officials said retrocession can be a challenge because tribes would lose access to state public safety and justice services.
In the lower 48 states, tribes named in the law may face limits on some public safety and justice funding, GAO said. Its review of Bureau of Indian Affairs data found that, from fiscal 2017 through fiscal 2021, tribes in states named in the law received less funding per person than tribes in all other states. Bureau officials told GAO they have limited money they can assign by choice and generally give priority to tribes that do not receive those services from their states.
Some earlier research suggests the law may have adverse effects on public safety and justice, including slow police response times and limited access to certain federal funding, according to GAO.
GAO was asked to review the law’s effect on tribal public safety and justice. It has already issued a separate report on the law in Alaska. This review covers how jurisdiction is exercised in the continental United States other than Alaska, and what federal research and data show about the law’s effect on tribes there.
GAO analyzed relevant laws and federal memoranda on tribal jurisdiction, and federal crime and funding data for fiscal years 2017 through 2024, which it called the most recent data available. It interviewed Bureau of Indian Affairs and Department of Justice officials, outside stakeholders and legal scholars, and tribal leaders and state law enforcement officials from three states covered by the law.
GAO recommended that Congress consider two changes. One would let tribes start retrocession and, once the Secretary of the Interior accepts it, make federal criminal authority exclusive of any state. The other would require tribal consent before a state offers to return its jurisdiction under the law to the secretary. Both matters for congressional consideration remain open.