The Government Accountability Office on Monday reported that selected traffic engineers and other practitioners said they never or rarely depart from federal standards for signs, signals and pavement markings.
Those devices tell roadway users about warnings and guidance. Uniform designs are meant to promote safety and efficiency by reducing confusion when people travel between towns or states. The Federal Highway Administration issues the Manual on Uniform Traffic Control Devices for Streets and Highways to set national criteria for the devices.
Almost all practitioners the office interviewed said they treat the manual as the authoritative source of standards and guidance. The highway administration allows departures under certain conditions, including to protect vulnerable road users. Almost all of those practitioners said they have never or rarely done so.
Many told the office that departures risk weakening uniformity. Several said they had departed occasionally to save on costs or to address a local issue affecting efficiency or safety. Many traffic engineers were reluctant to depart because a crash at that site could lead to a lawsuit.
Safety organizations have expressed concern that engineers may be unwilling to depart even when doing so might make roads safer for pedestrians and cyclists, the report says. The office was asked to review how practitioners depart from the manual to protect those users.
The highway administration revises the manual and considers practitioner feedback, including change requests and successful experiments that tested new devices or applications. The most recent edition is the 11th, from 2023. The report cites examples in that edition of devices intended to enhance safety for vulnerable road users.
The agency maintains a public online database of requests for experiments, interpretations and changes. The office found that the database provides few details on experiments or change requests. Officials told the office they have the information and provide it upon request, but the website does not clearly state that option, and many practitioners are unaware of it.
The office said clearer notice on the website would give practitioners greater access to experiment information. That information could help them prepare their own requests and test devices on roads they operate, which the office said would promote the manual’s objectives of safety and efficiency.
The office recommended that the highway administration prominently display contact information and clear instructions on the manual’s website for obtaining more detailed information on experiments in the rulings database. The Department of Transportation agreed. The recommendation is open. The office said it will provide updated information after confirming what actions the agency has taken.
The review covered the manual, the Official Rulings Database, other parts of the website, and relevant regulations and statutes. The office interviewed agency officials and practitioners in a sample of 26 city, county and state jurisdictions that was not designed to represent the nation as a whole. It also interviewed traffic engineers and other practitioners from five chosen professional membership organizations.