The U.S. Government Accountability Office on Wednesday said the Department of Health and Human Services and the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services should better manage fraud risks in traditional Medicare.
The findings cover the Medicare Fee-for-Service program, which CMS and its contractors oversee. CMS reported spending nearly $481 billion on benefits for about 34 million Medicare beneficiaries in 2025, according to the office.
Medicare is the largest federal health program. It has been on the office’s High Risk List since 1990 because of its size, complexity, effect on the federal budget and the health care sector, and continued susceptibility to fraud, mismanagement and improper payments, the report says.
CMS uses a Vulnerability Management Process inside its Center for Program Integrity to manage fraud risks. The office said that process is broader in scope and does not fully reflect the range of fraud risks Medicare faces.
Without fully identifying and assessing those risks in line with leading practices, the center is missing opportunities to limit fraud risks before they become significant fraud, the report says. The office said aligning the process with its Fraud Risk Framework could help reduce fraud and safeguard taxpayer money.
From Inspector General reports, the office identified fraud risks affecting Medicare that the center did not identify or assess in that process. The process also does not assess how likely fraud risks are or how large their impact would be, and it does not examine whether existing controls are suitable, the report says.
Medical equipment suppliers could potentially circumvent the program’s enrollment screening, leaving it open to fraud, the office found. The center had identified a vulnerability tied to that screening. The office called it a significant fraud risk because of its association with cases of alleged Medicare fraud. The center’s assessment did not assess the likelihood and impact of that vulnerability as a fraud risk. Without that assessment, the center risks overlooking the full scope and impact of fraud risks, according to the office.
The office was asked to review the department’s efforts to prevent and minimize fraud in Medicare. It reviewed documentation on Medicare risk assessments and related guidance, analyzed Inspector General reports, federal court documents and interviews from various contractors, and compared that information with its Fraud Risk Framework and internal control requirements. It interviewed and reviewed information reported from the department’s Office of the Assistant Secretary for Financial Resources, CMS and the Center for Program Integrity.
The office made four recommendations to the department. Each is listed as open. The department agreed with three recommendations and did not agree with one. The office said all four recommendations remain valid, as discussed in the report.
The recommendations ask the Secretary of Health and Human Services to direct officials to act. One would establish a way for the Center for Program Integrity to regularly report identified Medicare fraud risks and related antifraud efforts to the assistant secretary for financial resources. Others would have the CMS administrator ensure the center finalizes draft Fee-for-Service risk-management guidance, updates and finalizes draft risk assessments and vulnerability summaries, and revises its process overview so the center designs and regularly performs comprehensive fraud-risk assessments. Those steps should be consistent with leading practices and internal control requirements discussed in the report, the office said.