Every article on this site is written by AI from official sources and checked by a second AI. How it works

GAO says ICE should study costs before more detention purchases

The Government Accountability Office (GAO) said in a report released Thursday that U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement has not determined whether its new detention investments are cost effective. The agency also has not updated its spending plan to reflect its current efforts, GAO found.

ICE received $45 billion for immigration detention in July 2025 through Public Law 119-21, known as the One Big Beautiful Bill Act. The money is available through fiscal year 2029. ICE used some of it to run existing facilities and to start a plan to buy and renovate warehouses as detention sites.

Median daily cost per detained noncitizen, fiscal year 2025, by facility type
Facility typeDaily rate
Federal Bureau of Prisons (nine facilities)$180 median
Privately operated$151 median
U.S. Marshals Service or state and local agreements$85 to $103
Source: U.S. Government Accountability Office.

According to GAO, ICE bought 11 warehouses for about $1.07 billion. It then cut the effort back substantially and intends to sell seven of the warehouses. ICE also purchased four already-operating detention facilities in July and August 2026, paying roughly $2.2 billion altogether. GAO said the scope, time frames and estimated costs of further purchases remain undetermined.

GAO said ICE did not update its detention spending plan as its internal guidance requires. As a result, the plan includes an inflated estimate of planned obligations, which GAO said affects oversight and ICE’s ability to assess long-term budget needs. Obligations are amounts the agency has committed to spend.

GAO also said ICE did not manage detention investments in line with Department of Homeland Security acquisition practices, which include life-cycle cost estimates. These estimates project the full cost of an asset over its lifetime. GAO said developing them before more purchases would help ICE assess the investments and reduce potential waste. In an earlier report, GAO said ICE rapidly carried out the warehouse effort before scaling it down, likely leading to waste.

The report also covers costs. ICE obligated about $2.8 billion for detention in fiscal year 2025, up about 41% from the prior year, as enforcement expanded. The median daily rate per detained noncitizen was $180 at the nine Federal Bureau of Prisons facilities ICE used, the highest of any type. Privately operated facilities had a median of $151. Sites operated under arrangements with the U.S. Marshals Service, or with state and local governments, had rates between $85 and $103. ICE officials told GAO that services, detention standards and location also affect rates.

GAO said the rapid growth strained oversight. The workload of staff who oversee facilities and check invoices rose significantly, and ICE is working to fill 55 of 87 allocated positions nationwide.

GAO made two recommendations. The first is that the ICE director make sure spending plans for detention funds are updated on time and include all required elements. The second is that the director, working with the Homeland Security undersecretary for management, develop life-cycle cost estimates and evaluate alternatives before any significant future detention investments. The Department of Homeland Security agreed with both. GAO lists both as open and said it will provide updates once it confirms what ICE has done.

The report said a January 2025 executive order directed the department to increase detention of people apprehended for immigration violations. GAO said it was asked to review the costs of ICE’s detention facilities. The source does not say who made the request.

  1. Immigration Detention: ICE Should Determine Cost Effectiveness of New Initiatives Before Continuing — U.S. Government Accountability Office
How this article was made
Written with
Claude Sonnet 5.5 (Anthropic)
Fact-checked by
GPT-5 (OpenAI) — passed after revision
Generated
Nov. 19, 2026, 3:39 p.m. ET
Sources used
1 official source, listed above
Article type
Standard

The AI wrote only from the sources listed. No human reporter was involved. Read our standards or compare the models in the AI Report Card.