Superfund is the federal program for cleaning up contaminated sites. According to the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), Superfund, formally the Comprehensive Environmental Response, Compensation, and Liability Act, empowers the agency to clean up some of the most contaminated land and waterways in the country.
The EPA says its Superfund enforcement program has “potentially responsible parties,” often called PRPs, clean up sites. They do this either by funding the work or by doing it themselves under EPA oversight.
Two kinds of cleanup
The EPA says a cleanup at a Superfund site takes one of two forms: a removal action or a remedial action. A removal action is a short-term effort to steady a hazardous incident or take out contamination that threatens people’s health or the environment. The agency lists chemical explosions, hazardous spills and mercury exposures as examples.
Removal actions come in three kinds. An emergency action is immediate. A time-critical action takes place within six months. A non-time-critical action follows six months of planning.
A remedial action is a long-term cleanup for contamination that is a risk to human health and the environment. The EPA gives an old factory or a landfill as examples. Remedial cleanups sometimes start after a removal action. If an immediate risk turns up during a remedial cleanup, a removal action can be taken to deal with it.
Finding and notifying responsible parties
According to the EPA, a search for responsible parties begins once the agency decides that a site needs cleanup. The goal is to identify all parties responsible for the contamination. These can be people, businesses and government entities. Researchers look at who has owned and operated facilities at the site and match the hazardous substances found there to parties who may be liable. The EPA may ask PRPs and community members for information, and the search can continue throughout the cleanup.
Once a PRP is identified, the agency typically sends a general notice letter about possible liability at the site. The EPA says this letter can open communication and start negotiations over a cleanup agreement. When the agency is ready to negotiate, it may send a special notice letter. That letter explains why the EPA thinks the PRP is liable and describes the agency’s plans for the site. It also offers the PRP a chance to negotiate an agreement to do the cleanup work, pay for the agency’s costs, or both.
Settlements, orders and lawsuits
Many of the EPA’s enforcement tools are settlement agreements between the agency and a PRP. The EPA says these agreements formalize the work a PRP must do, including activities related to community involvement. The most common ones, often called work agreements, cover site investigations, removal cleanups and remedial cleanups. Many include a statement of work, a technical document that outlines the PRP’s cleanup work and the community engagement it should support.
The EPA says settlement agreements do not decide what kind of work is needed. The agency makes that decision based on investigations and studies of the contamination and the cleanup options.
Remedial work often begins with a Remedial Investigation, a study of how far the contamination extends. A Feasibility Study then develops and evaluates a range of cleanup methods. The EPA can negotiate with a PRP to perform both under an Administrative Settlement Agreement and Order on Consent. The study information is used to develop the EPA’s proposed plan and record of decision, which selects a remedy for the site.
Remedial work then includes a Remedial Design, which holds the engineering designs and technologies needed to meet the record of decision. The Remedial Action is the construction and cleanup itself. The enforcement tool for this stage is a consent decree. The EPA says it requires public review and comment and court approval before the PRP’s work can begin.
If a PRP appears unwilling to settle, the EPA can issue a Unilateral Administrative Order requiring the cleanup, or it can file suit. The agency says it may use such an order only when a site poses an immediate danger to public health or the environment. In an emergency, the EPA usually does removal work itself and takes enforcement action against the PRP later to recover its costs.
Recovering cleanup costs
The EPA says that when it pays for cleanup work out of Superfund money, it seeks repayment of those costs from the responsible parties. It must document all costs, and the records must show the costs were actually incurred and paid by the government. Work by contractors must be shown to be authorized and completed.
The agency describes three types of response costs. Direct costs are traced to a particular activity, such as staff time, travel, contractor costs and equipment at the site. Contractors’ annual allocation costs are site-related spending that cannot be traced to one site, such as hazardous-materials training. Contractors spread these across the sites they worked on during the year, and the EPA treats them as direct costs. Indirect costs are the agency’s expenses for managing itself, such as administrative, personnel, and office and utility costs.
According to the EPA, it decides whether to pursue cost recovery based on several factors. These include the strength of the liability evidence, the financial strength of the PRPs and the amount to be recovered. As a matter of policy, the agency sends a written demand letter before filing a lawsuit. The letter asks PRPs to reimburse the Superfund Trust Fund and triggers prejudgement interest on the costs sought.
PRPs generally try to negotiate how much of the cost they owe. A settlement may be recorded in a judicial consent decree or an administrative settlement. If a payment is overdue, a PRP refuses to pay, or no settlement can be reached, the Department of Justice files a cost recovery action in court.
The EPA says it may recover all costs that are “not inconsistent” with the National Contingency Plan. Courts have found costs recoverable for planning and carrying out cleanups, investigation and monitoring, and limiting access to a site. The agency pursues past costs and anticipated future costs. The agency may put money it recovers in settlements into dedicated accounts inside the Superfund Trust Fund, to be spent on cleanup at the site the money came from.
The EPA also describes time limits for going to court. It says there is some variation by site, but generally a removal action’s initial court action must begin within three years after the removal is completed. For a remedial action, it must begin within six years after physical on-site construction starts.
States, communities and reuse
The EPA says Superfund encourages state participation. The agency must notify a state about certain PRP negotiations and let the state take part, and states sometimes join the EPA in consent decrees.
The EPA says its negotiations with PRPs are confidential and closed to the public. When a negotiation involves technical information that can change cleanup decisions, however, the agency says it will notify the public and offer a comment period. The information used to select a remedy goes into the site’s administrative record, which is shared on the agency’s website. The public can also comment when a settlement is filed with a court.
The agency says it uses community meetings, public notices and other communications. It may require PRPs to help with the Community Involvement Plan, keep site documents at a place near the site, and submit a plan addressing impacts such as dust, traffic and noise.
The EPA also says Superfund has protections for parties interested in reusing contaminated or formerly contaminated property. These cover bona fide prospective purchasers, contiguous property owners and innocent landowners. The agency also uses comfort/status letters and Prospective Purchaser Agreements to address liability concerns about reuse.