Every article on this site is written by AI from official sources and checked by a second AI. How it works

USDA delays 2024 horse soring rule again, to Dec. 31, 2027

Part of our Federal Regulation coverage: background and related stories
File photo of a dairy farm in Monroe County, Wisconsin
File photo: A dairy farm in Monroe County, Wisconsin. Carol M. Highsmith Archive, Library of Congress

The Animal and Plant Health Inspection Service (APHIS) has again delayed the effective date of its 2024 Horse Protection rule, this time to Dec. 31, 2027. The Agriculture Department agency issued the final rule, which is set to be published in the Federal Register on Monday, Nov. 23, 2026. The agency said the delay takes effect immediately.

The delay covers the parts of the 2024 rule that a federal court did not throw out. Those parts amend sections 11.1 through 11.18 of the horse protection regulations. According to the agency, the Horse Protection Act aims to end soring, a cruel practice involving horses, and to promote fair competition.

Postponements of the 2024 Horse Protection rule
Postponement publishedNew effective date
Jan. 28, 2025April 2, 2025
March 21, 2025Feb. 1, 2026
Jan. 28, 2026Dec. 31, 2026
Nov. 23, 2026Dec. 31, 2027
Source: Agriculture Department, Animal and Plant Health Inspection Service.

APHIS said the postponement is needed because of a separate proposal. On Nov. 13, 2026, the agency proposed removing the parts of the 2024 rule that a court vacated, meaning struck down. It also proposed withdrawing the rest of the 2024 rule and updating the current regulations. Public comments on that proposal are due Dec. 14, 2026.

The agency said that comment period ends too close to the current Dec. 31, 2026, effective date for it to review comments and issue a final rule in time. Letting the partly vacated 2024 rule take effect first would “almost certainly” cause disruption, the agency said. It said this “regulatory whiplash” could be costly to the regulated industry. APHIS said the delay gives it time to review comments and, if appropriate, issue a final rule.

The 2024 rule has been postponed several times. APHIS published the rule on May 8, 2024, with most provisions due to take effect on Feb. 1, 2025. Only section 11.19 took effect earlier, on June 7, 2024.

A lawsuit by the Tennessee Walking Horse National Celebration Association challenged the rule in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Texas. On Jan. 31, 2025, the court vacated provisions on action devices, pads and substances, on a skin-condition test meant to replace the “scar rule,” and on inspection reviews and appeals. The court upheld the rule’s replacement of the Designated Qualified Persons program with Horse Protection Inspectors.

A second lawsuit, Gould v. U.S. Department of Agriculture, was filed June 30, 2025. In a footnote, APHIS said the court granted summary judgment to the plaintiffs on Aug. 28, 2026. It found that the “No-Showback Rule” and the scar rule exceed USDA’s legal authority. It also found that USDA’s process for disqualifying horses does not provide adequate due process.

APHIS also cited a House Appropriations Committee report on the fiscal 2026 agriculture spending bill. The committee directed APHIS to withdraw the 2024 rule and work with the industry on objective, science-based methods to end soring. APHIS said that in 2025 it received 6,124 submissions, representing 93,734 comments, on how long to extend the earlier postponement.

APHIS said it did not seek public comment on this delay. It cited a legal exception for good cause, saying there is not enough time for another comment round before Dec. 31, 2026. It said it is taking comment on the Nov. 13 proposal instead.

The document lists Martha Keller, director of the Center for Animal Welfare at APHIS Animal Care, as the contact for more information. It gives her phone number as (970) 821-5734.

  1. Horse Protection Amendments; Extension of Postponement of Regulations — Agriculture Department, Animal and Plant Health Inspection Service
How this article was made
Written with
Claude Sonnet 5.5 (Anthropic)
Fact-checked by
GPT-5 (OpenAI) — passed
Generated
Nov. 21, 2026, 1:39 a.m. ET
Sources used
1 official source, listed above
Article type
Standard

The AI wrote only from the sources listed. No human reporter was involved. Read our standards or compare the models in the AI Report Card.